CROSS Safety Report
Fibrous plaster ceiling features
This report is over 2 years old
This recent report of a serious concern about an old fibrous plaster ceiling has similarities to the Apollo Theatre ceiling collapse in London in December 2013.
It is thought that complete collapse was averted by the arched shape of the trough section and that if the ceiling was flat collapse would have occurred.
Key Learning Outcomes
For building owners and managers:
Be aware that all structures including ceilings will degrade with time
Regular inspections and maintenance can help keep a structure/ element safe. Inspections should be carried out by a competent person who is suitably qualified
For construction professionals and design engineers:
Ceiling design and installation should be given the same degree of attention as the primary structure during both design and construction to improve safety, reliability and longevity
Consider appointing a single entity (or Chartered Engineer) to have overall control of the design of the ceiling system. This would include overseeing its interfaces with the support structure and to assure the ability of the structure to support the applied loads.
Find out more about the Full Report
The Full Report below has been submitted to CROSS and describes the reporter’s experience. The text has been edited for clarity and to ensure anonymity and confidentiality by removing any identifiable details. If you would like to know more about our secure reporting process or submit a report yourself, please visit the reporting to CROSS-UK page.
This recent report of a serious concern about an old fibrous plaster ceiling has similarities to the Apollo Theatre ceiling collapse in London in December 2013. In retrieving a helium party balloon, says the reporter, a crack was discovered in a down-standing feature arch in a local authority hall built circa 1926. On closer inspection this was a non-structural plaster trough section with ornate scroll features. The crack 6mm wide was present over two thirds of the span and occurred on both sides.
Support of ceiling trough feature
Inspection from the roof space revealed a system of small timber battens (30x18mm) tied together with hessian ‘wadding’ type rope with ‘balls’ of plaster around the joints – there was no mechanical fixings. The assembly was suspended from timber joists by similar wadding rope wrapped around the joist.
Closer inspection reveals further concerns and defects
Many of the wadding ropes were snapped at various places around the loop. Sometimes this was hidden below the joist, at the side or on top, particularly if there were signs of past crawl boards having been placed upon the rope or dragged over them. Where ties were intact, they could be snapped by finger pressure.
Closer examination of the wadding rope showed a high volume of plaster in the cross section and upon crushing, the fibres were found to be interwoven confirming the origin of rolled cloth impregnated with plaster rather than preformed rope dipped in plaster. The hessian strings had fully degraded and could be pulled apart with light finger pressure.
Ceiling collapse averted
It is thought that complete collapse was averted by the arched shape of the trough section and that if the ceiling was flat, prior collapse would have occurred. The estimated dead load of the trough is 1.51kN/m (154kg/m) and it is 11m to the crown. Two other halls (with flat ceilings) were inspected and found to have down-stand architectural features with similar wadding ropes.
Concerns for similar public buildings
Past reports have highlighted ‘theatres’ and there has been recent issue of Guidance Note 20, by the Association of British Theatre Technicians (ABTT). The concern is there must be many similar public buildings including council chambers/meeting rooms, town/concert/assembly halls, schools/university buildings, and stately homes that are not specifically designated as a ‘theatre’ that may have circa 90 year old fibrous plaster ceilings.
Clearly fully inspection of these ties is extremely difficult and in this case, it was considered all ties were suspect (as all examined were) and alternative means of support were installed. The reporter hopes that his photos will help to pass on the message that these may be hazardous.
Expert Panel Comments
Find out more about the Expert Panels
Expert Panels comment on the reports we receive. They use their experience to help you understand what can be learned from the reports. If you would like to know more, please visit the CROSS-UK Expert Panels page.
This is an issue of real and immediate concern and duplicates the findings following the Apollo Theatre Collapse when 88 patrons were injured as plasterwork fell during a performance.
When hessian ties are holding up heavy ceilings in places of public assembly there is a risk of failure when the ties deteriorate as described above. There may also be loading changes if lights or other items have been added over the years and there may be dynamic effects which exacerbate the situation.
In February 2014 Westminster City Council said:
‘As a result (of the Apollo Theatre incident), we recommend that in addition to what was stated in the interim guidance the wadding ties of all suspended ornate ceilings are thoroughly inspected from above as a matter of urgency by a competent historic plaster specialist and a structural engineer.’
In response to the Apollo incident The Association of British Theatre Technicians (ABTT) published Guidance Note 20 – Suspended Fibrous Plaster Ceilings in May 2015. This has been compiled by specialists in the field and provides excellent guidance. More publicity is needed about the potential risks to other buildings and local and national government agencies and others are asked to draw attention to these.
Submit a report
Your report will make a difference. It will help to create positive change and improve safety.
Our secure and confidential safety reporting system gives professionals the opportunity to share their experiences to help others.
No feedback has yet been published for this page.