CROSS Safety Report
Water ingress to cross-laminated timber structural frame
In an eight year old building that included cross-laminated timber construction, it was found that water penetration had caused parts of the structure to rot. This was not apparent from external inspection.
Key Learning Outcomes
For construction professionals:
- Design in ‘inspectability’ of key building components including structure
- Be aware of the risks associated with moisture build-up, particularly where timber is a main component
- Good detailing can be key to controlling water ingress
- Beware of the potential for condensation within external walls
- Ventilation requirements must be considered to control condensation in buildings
- Consider the knowledge and experience required to sign-off compliance of specialist packages such as CLT
Find out more about the Full Report
The Full Report below has been submitted to CROSS and describes the reporter’s experience. The text has been edited for clarity and to ensure anonymity and confidentiality by removing any identifiable details. If you would like to know more about our secure reporting process or submit a report yourself, please visit the reporting to CROSS-UK page.
A reporter had been involved with remedial works on a project that was built about 8 years previously and included cross-laminated timber (CLT). The external walls had insulation covering CLT panels and it was found that due to quality issues with the original wall construction, there had been water penetration which caused parts of the CLT to rot in localised areas.
This was a serious concern because the rot was hidden behind the insulation and so was only identified when significant amounts of intrusive investigations into the external wall construction were carried out. Visual inspection from outside the building would not have identified this issue. This means that if the investigations had not been carried out, over a longer time period (e.g., 10 to 20 years) the rot might well have become much more extensive.
When CLT is used it typically forms the structural frame and so there is a risk that poor waterproofing could cause the frame to deteriorate over time with no outward sign of the deterioration. The reporter considered the cause of the water ingress was likely poor workmanship, poor design, or a combination of both.
For new buildings that include CLT, says the reporter, it is vital to emphasise the importance of effective waterproofing through good design and construction. It is much more important for a CLT building than it would be for buildings with more conventional types of structure, for example, reinforced concrete.
The reporter considers that for existing buildings that include CLT, the owners and anyone surveying them, should be aware of this issue and ensure that adequate checks are carried out, although in practice it is a difficult issue to investigate without extensive intrusive investigations.
Submit a report
Your report will make a difference. It will help to create positive change and improve safety.
Our secure and confidential safety reporting system gives professionals the opportunity to share their experiences to help others.
No feedback has yet been published for this page.
Expert Panel Comments
Expert Panels comment on the reports we receive. They use their experience to help you understand what can be learned from the reports. If you would like to know more, please visit the CROSS-UK Expert Panels page.
This report highlights the importance of understanding a structure, and knowing where there are hidden critical components. Where unseen deterioration could lead to a failure and components cannot be inspected then ‘beware’.
A theme that occurs in many CROSS reports is ‘inspectability’. The object of an inspection is to detect a problem before it progresses far enough to become structurally dangerous. In this case, it looks as if there was no way of knowing that the timber was rotting. With a trend for increasingly greater use of CLT in buildings, including tall buildings, it is critical to ensure protection of susceptible materials from water and from other potential hazards.
Unfortunately, poor detailing which allows water ingress can badly affect all building types, causing failures in different ways including providing environments that are damp and hazardous to health. These issues are often difficult and expensive to resolve. CROSS report Rotting of cross-laminated timber (CLT) roof panels published in 2019 similarly concerned hidden structural members which had deteriorated due to an ingress of water. This report also considered the subject of internally generated condensation in buildings which can be really problematic and again lead to deterioration of structural elements including timber as well as causing all manner of unacceptable non-structural effects. BS 5250:2021 gives recommendations and guidance on avoiding problems with high moisture levels and condensation in buildings.
good detailing and construction of weatherproofing systems are essential
Water and moisture generally are contributing factors to much deterioration and failure of buildings. Good detailing and construction of weatherproofing systems are essential. A lack of routine maintenance may also play a part and lead to deterioration.
Deterioration can contribute to the collapse of structures. The ice rink roof collapsed onto skaters in Bad Reichenhall, Bavaria, Germany, in 2006 killing fifteen people. There was not a single cause of the collapse but a series of several defects and damage. The design capacity of the failed elements was found to be inadequate and this capacity was further reduced over the life of the structure due to deterioration in the timber box girders. The structure was about 34 years old at collapse.
not a single cause of the collapse but a series of several defects and damage
CROSS published an important article Cross-laminated timber (CLT) in multi-storey buildings in 2021 concerning interpretation and application of the Building Act 1984 with respect to the use of CLT in multi-storey buildings.
A checklist of water damage published in the Institution of Civil Engineers publication ‘Forensic Engineering’ overviews the wide range of causes of damage from water in the built environment and provides further information that can be considered during design or to help investigate problems.