CROSS Safety Report
Principal designers’ obligations for temporary works
This report is over 2 years old
A correspondent believes that the new BS5975 standard places some onerous temporary work duties on the principal designer.
They question whether many principal designer organisations will have the competence to coordinate temporary works designs in an effective manner.
Key Learning Outcomes
For principal designers and construction professionals:
Be aware that CDM Regulations 2015 sets out the legal duties of the principal designer, whereas BS 5975 provides authoritative industry guidance on how those legal duties might be complied with
The Temporary Works forum (TWf) is a source of useful information on this topic, and published Information Sheet 3 - CDM 2015 - Principal Designer: Guidance on Temporary Works in 2017
Find out more about the Full Report
The Full Report below has been submitted to CROSS and describes the reporter’s experience. The text has been edited for clarity and to ensure anonymity and confidentiality by removing any identifiable details. If you would like to know more about our secure reporting process or submit a report yourself, please visit the reporting to CROSS-UK page.
A correspondent has contacted CROSS as they are concerned by the principal designer’s obligations for temporary works as stated in Clause 8.5 of the new BS 5975:2019 standard (Code of practice for temporary works procedures and the permissible stress design of falsework).
They believe that the standard places some onerous duties on the principal designer which are a long way removed from site work. They question whether many principal designer organisations will have the competence to coordinate temporary works designs in an effective manner.
They worry that we have gone from a single ultimate point of responsibility for temporary works to a situation where there is a confusing overlap of duties, roles and responsibilities.
The correspondent concludes by asking if anyone is aware of any guidance on how this will work in practice?
Submit a report
Your report will make a difference. It will help to create positive change and improve safety.
Our secure and confidential safety reporting system gives professionals the opportunity to share their experiences to help others.
No feedback has yet been published for this page.
Expert Panel Comments
Expert Panels comment on the reports we receive. They use their experience to help you understand what can be learned from the reports. If you would like to know more, please visit the CROSS-UK Expert Panels page.
The Temporary Works forum (TWf) is a source of useful information on this topic, including the publication of Information Sheet 3 - CDM 2015 - Principal Designer: Guidance on Temporary Works in 2017. This document states that the principal designer should, at an early stage, discuss and agree with the client their approach to the delivery of the role with respect to temporary works. Another useful reference is the Temporary Works Toolkit published in The Structural Engineer.
Legal duties of the principal designer
It is important to remember the distinction between the duties as required by law, and recommendations provided by industry guidance. CDM 2015 sets out the legal duties of the principal designer, whereas BS 5975 provides authoritative industry guidance on how those legal duties might be complied with. The principal designer is free to ignore the guidance if they wish, or do something different, but ultimately, they must ensure that they comply with their lawful duties as set out in CDM 2015.
Does CDM 2015 distinguish between permanent and temporary works design?
Further to this, CDM 2015 does not distinguish between permanent works design and temporary works design. They are both design as far as CDM 2015 is concerned with the same duties imposed on designers and principal designers of both permanent and temporary works.
It is up to those organisations providing principal designer services to ensure that they have the necessary capability to undertake the role either in-house or by making suitable arrangements to supplement their capabilities. If not, they are potentially in breach of CDM 2015 Regulation 8(1) which requires that:
It is up to those organisations providing principal designer services to ensure that they have the necessary capability to undertake the role either in-house or by making suitable arrangements to supplement their capabilities
Items for principal designers to consider for temporary works
The statements and intent within the updated BS 5975 look to direct clients to engage principal designers that can provide the support that CDM 2015 intends. This would include guidance on temporary works coordination and the consideration of permanent works and buildability.
Items which a principal designer could consider in relation to temporary works include:
Ensure that the permanent works designers have identified a coherent construction method which identifies all key temporary works requirements
Ensure that adequate temporary works coordination processes are in place
Ensure effective communication between permanent works designers and temporary works designers
Provide relevant information that may affect temporary works
If temporary works (and their risks) can be eliminated by designing the permanent works in a different manner
How risks for temporary works, if they are required, can be minimised
Determining is there sufficient space for temporary works during construction, maintenance and demolition
Determining if other stakeholders need to be consulted about any temporary works.
There may be other considerations depending upon the circumstances.